You Have More Reviews. Why Does the Other Business Show Up First?

Reading Time: 5 minutes

You have spent years asking customers for reviews. You have more of them than the competitor down the road, and a better rating. Yet when someone searches for what you do, their business appears first. It feels unfair, and it raises a fair question: what do reviews actually do for your ranking?

Reviews matter. They are not the only thing that matters, and Google says so plainly. The checks below can narrow down the likely reasons the other business shows up first, even if they cannot reveal the full explanation, and they show which parts are in your control.

A quick first check

  1. Run the same search from two locations (or ask someone across town to search). If the order changes, distance may be part of the reason. It does not prove distance is the only one.
  2. Compare the primary category and services listed on their profile against yours to see whether their profile describes the searched service more completely.
  3. Search the competitor’s business name on Google to find examples of local chambers, associations or community sites that list them. Treat what you find as examples, not a complete count.

How does Google rank local results?

Google says local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and popularity. The same page heads that third factor as Prominence:

FactorWhat it meansCan you change it?
RelevanceHow well your profile matches what the person searched forYes, through accurate categories, services and details
DistanceHow far your business is from the customer who is searchingNot really. You cannot move closer to every customer
ProminenceHow well known your business is, including links to it and its reviewsPartly, over time

Google says these factors work together, and it keeps its ranking details confidential, so it does not say how much weight each factor gets. In practice, that means no single factor, reviews included, decides the order on its own.

Where do reviews fit?

Reviews sit under prominence. Google’s ranking help page says prominence is based on information like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking.

So reviews help, but they are one input into one of three factors. If the competitor is closer to the searcher or matches the search better, your extra reviews may not close the gap.

Get a one-location checklist that compares your Google Business Profile, reviews and local links the way Google and your customers see them.

Get the Local SEO Audit Checklist

Why does the other business show up first?

Check all four. Start with the search location and wording, because those are the quickest differences to test.

  1. Where was the search done? A search from across town may produce a different order, because Google considers where the searcher is. Distance may help explain why a business with fewer reviews appears first, but Google does not disclose how much it counts against reviews.
  2. What exactly was searched? If a customer searches “emergency plumber,” check whether each business uses an accurate category and lists its services completely. Google says services you list may be highlighted when customers search for them, and warns against using categories only as keywords. A difference here is worth investigating, but it does not prove why one ranks first.
  3. How complete is each profile? Google says businesses with complete and accurate information, such as address, hours and category, are more likely to show up in local results.
  4. How well known is each business on the web? Google counts links to your business as part of prominence, so a competitor that more local websites link to can have more prominence even with fewer reviews.

What can you not do?

Google states that there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Be wary of anyone who offers to sell one.

Also keep review requests within Google’s rules. Google’s Maps content policy does not allow businesses to offer payment, discounts or free goods in exchange for reviews, or to ask only happy customers for them, and says incentivized reviews will be removed. If a profile problem turns into a suspension, see what to do when your Google Business Profile is suspended. If the profile does not appear at all, start with why your business is not showing up on Google Maps.

A worked example

Two accounting firms sit 4 miles apart. Firm A has 180 reviews. Firm B has 60, but is located in the neighborhood where the searcher is, lists “bookkeeping” and “payroll” as services, and is linked from the local chamber of commerce and several community sites. For a search of “bookkeeper near me” from that neighborhood, Firm B can show first. Firm A’s best moves are to complete its services and categories, keep earning reviews, and earn links from local organizations, not to chase a review count.

Key takeaways

  • Google ranks local results on relevance, distance and prominence together.
  • Reviews add to prominence, along with how many websites link to your business.
  • Distance is the factor you control least, and Google does not say how much it counts against reviews.
  • Complete, accurate profile details help Google match you to the right searches.
  • You cannot pay Google to rank higher in local results, and Google says reviews given for payment, discounts or free goods will be removed.

The bottom line

More reviews are worth having, and they help, but they are one part of the picture. When a competitor shows up first, compare relevance and prominence before you assume it is about the review count. Our local SEO audit checklist and guide to the essential components of local SEO walk through the rest of the review.

Questions to answer about your own business

  • Where are most of your customers when they search for you, and how far is that from your address?
  • Do your category and services describe the jobs you most want, in the words customers use?
  • Which local organizations, suppliers or associations could list or link to your business?
  • How do you ask for reviews today, and do you ask every customer or only the happy ones?

Sources

If a competitor keeps showing up ahead of you, an Opportunity Review is a call where we look at the evidence available on how your profile compares with the businesses ranking first.

See What’s Holding Your Marketing Back

Get practical marketing insights for business owners in your inbox every week.

Get the ScaledOn Insider